Question:
for those of you who think linux is better than windows?
justanonlinename
2013-04-24 11:01:18 UTC
here are facts for you to consider.
windows is the most popular os in the world, for a reason. why ? it works, its user friendly, its the kind of os you could set up on a grandparents computer for them and easy to adapt to. Linux ? no. its poorly put together on most distributions. nowhere near as functional with certain drivers, software.
If you are a gamer, well lol don't even try compare games for Linux with windows pc games or you will look silly.
More facts, every version of Linux is like a work in production, its unfinished. with Microsoft, you are getting a fully finished OS not some botch job put together by random strangers.
With Microsoft you are getting a service from people paid to do a job, employees. customer service.
Other advantages. windows gives you access to a windows live mail account, your own personalized email, windows messenger . What does Linux have like that ? nothing....

sure Linux has no viruses or malware really, but why ? because hackers don't care about your inferior unimportant OS, it attacks the giants of the industry, well the giant, which is Microsoft.
Nine answers:
ratter_of_the_shire
2013-04-24 17:47:20 UTC
Better, always begs the question, better for what purpose.



As for the facts, Linux is a more popular OS is it runs on embedded devices and servers. Most people have at least two Linux machines in their home. (Their modem, and router)



Windows is the most popular desktop OS, but there are many other types of computers.



The big why of it is legacy applications. Windows was decisively first, people bought applications and hardware for windows and want to keep using that hardware. The next is people have spent a great deal of time learning how to use and troubleshoot windows just be having a windows computer. They don't was to spend to time to learn a new system.



Linux actually supports more hardware than any version of Windows, but just not necessarily the hardware the consumer may have bought off the shelf of a box store retailer in the past year. However support now is better than it's ever been and is improving with increased manufacturer support. Careful shopping nearly eliminates the issue.



Linux supports a great deal of portable API specifications for software, but it is a bit of a chicken and egg problem. Developers don't develop if there aren't consumers there, but you can't get a lot of consumers there until you have a wide variety of development to choose from. However emulation layers are improving, and more developers than ever are targeting a Linux platform.



As for distros, there are several that are well-tested and stable. But on the flip side it is an advantage. There are a lot more options available to suit a person's needs. Many of the distro's are commercial and put together by paid developers who are very good at their job.



The Live account is just a way for Microsoft to spy on you, whatever you do and wherever you go, but if you must have it you can sign onto it's services from Linux.



And yes customer service is harder to find for linux, but customer serviceability is highly increased. Users are more empowered to customize and change their systems as they see fit.



Right, but we know you are biased, as you gloss over the advantages of linux.



1. Freedom and customization. There is no lock-in, no artificial restrictions of features, and anything can be changed given you have enough knowledge and time to do it, or pay someone who does. How the pieces go together are more easily seen and manipulated, so you can also learn more about computers simply be virtue of using one than is possible with closed sources like windows.



2. Cutting edge features are often available first on Linux as a development cycle is measured in months rather than years.



3. Performance... can extend the life of old hardware while using secure up-to-date software, can choose lightweight and faster components of the desktop, and tweak performance in many subtle and interesting ways.



4. Stability. Not just up-time and the additional robustness of open code, but the fact drivers are in the kernel tree, meaning if it was working with an open driver before a major upgrade it will almost always be working after. Fewer updates require reboots, and some system don't require a reboot at all to complete routine upgrades (for a potential of up to 7 years fully upgraded continuous run-time of a server).



5. Package management. You can install, manage, and upgrade most of your applications with a single other application, saving time and headache. I also insures trusted sources are used as an additional layer of security.



6. Trust. Code you can trust, because it trusts you.
2013-04-24 19:54:24 UTC
Linux is not bad. It doesn't matter if it is popular, I would rather be the only one using the Operating System than using a bloated one. User friendly, some.



"Nowhere near functional with drivers" False. My drivers work fine on Pear Linux/Fedora/Linux Mint/Ubuntu and more. "Every version of Linux is in production" Linux isn't a Operating System, it is stated as the Linux Kernel, not a full Operating System. It is not poorly put together, it is one of the most elegant Desktop Environments I have ever used, such as Pear Linux 7, as I am using now, it's like a clone of Mac, but it is not the same.



Linux altogether is not a operating system, it is a kernel. Windows is bloated, and virus infected. Linux has Viruses and Malware, about 15. (Ha) Linux has messaging to, Empathy, Pigdin and more.



You are wrong, Linux is better than Windows, just because it doesn't have games or hackers all around it does not mean it is not a great Operating System/Kernel.



Linux is Updating, looking at your comment "Unfinished" Linux Distributionss are always patching with Security Updates and more.



Sorry, but I will have to disagree with this, I like Linux better than Windows, I am using a Fedora, Ubuntu, and Mac based Distributionn called Pear Linux 7. Elegant, Fast, and not bloated and loaded with bloatware out of the box.

Windows is good for casual web browsing and gaming, but Linux based Operating Systems have Speed, they are customizable, and not bloated.

Linux is easy to adapt to if you have the right distro.



-Elian
『  』
2013-04-24 20:17:53 UTC
<>



That is partially correct. MS Windows is the most popular Desktop Operating System. However, when you talk about MainFrames, Servers, Super Computers, Embedded Devices, &c., Linux beats Windows hands down. The most popular and most used Operating System in the world is not Linux nor Windows, it is actually ITRON http://www.linuxinsider.com/story/31855.html .



<>



Yes, and Linux is studied and coded by millions of programmers from around the world. Even MS is supporting Linux http://www.zdnet.com/blog/open-source/top-five-linux-contributor-microsoft/9254 . There are also Linux IRCs, forums, and one could find a LUG in their area to get help.



Also Red Hat Enterprise Linux, Novel Suse, Canonical Ubuntu, Vine Linux, &c., all have official support from a corporation just like Microsoft.



<>



Windows Live Account... I have a MS Live account that I never use, and I use Linux exclusively. Are you perhaps talking about MS Skydrive (cloud storage)? MS is supporting Linux on that front because most major corporations use Linux for their servers, mainframes, &c., and MS would not want to lose their support either. Also, there are other options out there, such as ownCloud, Openshift, &c. Linux also has a bunch electronic mail and chat software. You could even build your own personal mail server and truly personalize it.



<>



Wrong again, Linux is superiorly designed to begin with. There are millions of eyes looking through the code, and millions of users (this is to include corporations) who submit patches. So if there is a hole in the security of Linux 3.5.0; anything found during that kernel version, will be fixed by Linux 3.5.1. (which patches are commonly pushed through within days) The hole may effect that version only and so that exploit will not work for Linux 2.6.38, or Linux 3.6, or any other for that matter. Also one needs to take into account the architecture that is being used, the software, the distribution, the fact that the system is locked down at all times, the fact that most will get their software from a secure source (the distros repository which is digitally signed), &c. If you think about it, Linux is on way more servers than Windows (UNIX is also) http://arstechnica.com/business/2011/09/despite-enterprise-dominance-microsoft-struggles-in-web-server-market/



Note: since the majority of Linux distributions are available freely, a large portion of Linux servers are not accounted for in many market share statistics because these statics are approximated based on license sales.





The fact of the matter is, your argument is rather weak and lacking. I use Linux because I got tired to maintaining Windows. Even though I was constantly maintaining the Firewall, Anti-Virus/Malware, registry, filesystem, &c., my system eventually slowed to a crawl after three years. There was nothing that I could do to stop it. In every computer class which I have ever taken, a rule of thumb was; reinstalling Windows ever two years is mandatory. I have been using Linux since about 2007-2008 and didn't have such an issue. Once Linux was installed, there were no slow downs.



Also, have you ever installed Windows from scratch? It is a real pain in the behind having to hunt down all of the drivers. Linux will for the most part run right out of install as all of the drivers are built right in.



Truth be told, when I really got to play with Linux for a good six months, I experienced something new; actually having freedom with not only my hardware, but my software as well. Your computer is yours, not Microsoft's or Apple's. Have you ever noticed that MS is only leasing you a license to run their OS?



I also can't believe what they are doing with MS Office 2013. One license is tied to the hardware, or choose MS Office 365 and pay an annual fee.
Rose D
2013-04-24 18:41:09 UTC
Setting aside the fact that this isn't a question, you have a lot to learn about the computer industry.



Windows is the most popular OS in the world because Microsoft has contracts with the majority of PC manufacturers to install Windows on the computers they build. The majority of computer users don't even know what an OS is or that they have a choice. Of course, the initial statement is false - Windows isn't the most popular OS in the world. Linux actually dominates the market when you factor in mobile devices. Linux has 42% of the market overall while Microsoft only has 26%. Desktop PCs are no longer the dominant force they once were. Linux also has 60% of the server market as opposed to less than 40% for Windows. In short, Windows only dominates in the dying desktop PC arena.



As for how user friendly Linux is, my mother-in-law is 64 years old. She is a quilter who makes custom draperies. She uses Linux to run her business as well as her husband's business. She hasn't had any problems. My father is 79 years old and planning to switch to Linux since he refuses to use Windows 8. He's learning it in a VM that I set up for him. He likes it well enough.



And on the gaming front, Valve CEO Gabe Newell is enthusiastic about Linux gaming. He's working on porting Steam games to Linux and Mac OS. Other big names in the industry, including EA, are following his lead. Microsoft is losing ground in this arena as well.



With Microsoft, you do get a product from people paid to do a job. People who sued Microsoft for abusive hiring and work practices and who tend to be hired on H1B visas and paid less than the industry standard. Microsoft doesn't have a good reputation and can no longer hire top tier employees. They depend upon illegal use of temps and immigrants for a lot of their labor force. And as for shipping something that's unfinished, they release patches and updates every week to fix bugs. They release a new OS every 2 years or so.



Does anyone even use Windows Live Mail or Messenger? I thought they died years ago...
D A
2013-04-25 03:20:06 UTC
Well, personally I would use Linux for productive stuff like school and you have next to zero chance to infections. The reason why there are so many apps for Windows is because it is many times more popular than Linux, and more people use it and more coders for Windows than Linux. But as Linux grows.... this may not be a problem anymore.



Well, in my opinion, I like Windows more just because I'm used to it... Nothing much besides so gaming :)
Dixie Normus
2013-04-24 18:15:44 UTC
Again, strengths and weakness of each.



And I question your assertation "with Windows you are getting a fully finished OS"; Windows 2000 shipped with 64,000 bugs. Windows XP was considered a toy until SP2. Windows 8 is said to be killing the PC industry. And the less said about flubs like MS Bob and Windows ME, the better.



I'm not sure (well I am) what you're trying to accomplish, but you should use some critical thinking regarding your arguments.



And I'm not sure why you think you can't get Hotmail on a non-MS OS.
Charlie Kelly
2013-04-25 03:26:03 UTC
linux runs 90% of the internet, seems like hackers would be interested.



Traditionally hackers go for the 'low hanging fruit' which is normally windows, not always of course. There are fundamental differences in how linux and microsoft respond to threats, which microsoft's position is often to not act at all.
St N
2013-04-24 18:10:24 UTC
Yes. And Windows, like the ones in your house keeps breaking. It takes for ever to load. Virus scans, which are essential take hours and will crash other programs running. Windows is also an unfinished OS as then bring out a new version every few years and then immediately have to release patches to fix the errors and holes they left.



If all you want to do is play games, then get a game console. If all you want to do is watch movies get a TV and dvd/blu ray. For word processing, spread sheets and other business and academic applications they are equal and Mac is also in the running.
?
2013-04-24 18:01:58 UTC
im a windows fan but one thing about linux thats the best is the awsome logo


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Continue reading on narkive:
Loading...